In Nicholas Carr’s essay “Is Google
Making us Stupid?” he notes that the more time he spends online, the harder
time he has reading deeply and he struggles with concentration and
contemplation. Carr says that others have felt this too; they report
skimming texts instead of sustained attention. Recent studies back up these
claims. Carr interviews psychologist Maryanne Wolf who says the Internet, with
its emphasis on speed and volume, may be destroying our ability to engage
deeply with texts. Carr points out that Nietzsche’s writing style changed after
he acquired a typewriter, and even the invention of clocks affected the way
people think about themselves and their world. The Internet has changed
people’s thinking even more. It has even shaped traditional media to become
more like itself. Carr discusses Frederick Winslow Taylor who used a stopwatch
to promote efficiency in early factories. His ideas have become the cornerstone
of modern industry, and this approach has now come to dominate the Internet,
and by extension, thinking. Google is the best example of this, in
its effort to organize everything with the ultimate search engine. Carr wraps
up by suggesting that perhaps new technology has always changed the way we
think, but then again the Internet’s effect is deep and profound. He fears we
have become “pancake people:” wide but thin, and that human intelligence is
more and more resembling artificial intelligence.
In the Question of is Google making
us Dumb? There is really no definite answer on what exactly Google is doing to
people's intelligence. Reading Nicholas Carr's essay made me realize how
people today process information. You can say I agree and also disagree to
Nicholas Carr. I can agree that people now don't read more into a text in a
book, article, or anything that can be read, and that reading will not make you
understand what the text or even maybe comprehend the text. But in my opinion,
the way Google and any another big corporate social media
uses these fast skimming process of reading utilizes a fast way to
find important parts of the text. They made processing information more simple
and accessible to everyone. Thinking about how Frederick
Winslow used his stopwatch to promote efficiency in his
industry make me think that the way we use Google now also does the
same thing. Google provides a better way to find information in simple text and
also provide easy access to the things that people are
more interested in. So in conclusion, If you are a type of people who
likes to go in detail on what you are reading maybe Google is making
you dumb, but if you are a type of person that just want
to skim through text and just pick and choose on what you like
then Google is not making you dumb but it’s just giving you
a faster way to learn.
Your summary clearly indicates a progression towards your thesis statement, good work. The navigation of the summary is fluid and easily understood.
ReplyDelete